In a thrilling 2024-25 English Carabao Cup Third Round clash, Everton and Southampton faced off at Goodison Park, with both teams aiming for a crucial victory to advance. The match, laden with drama, showcased resilience and determination as it ended in a 1-1 draw after regular time, pushing the game into penalties where Southampton emerged victorious with a 6-5 win. This intense encounter kept fans on the edge of their seats as the two teams delivered a memorable contest in this year’s Carabao Cup.
Head-to-Head: Everton vs Southampton
Everton and Southampton have shared a competitive rivalry in domestic competitions, with the two sides often battling closely. Historically, Everton has had the upper hand in home matches, while Southampton has proven resilient in knockout competitions. This Carabao Cup clash was no different, with both sides pushing hard to secure a spot in the next round.
Everton vs Southampton Lineups
Here is the Everton vs Southampton lineups today (Sep 17, 2024)
Everton (4-2-3-1)
- Goalkeeper: João Virgínia
- Defenders: Jake O’Brien, Michael Keane, Roman Quintyne, Ashley Young
- Midfielders: Orel Mangala, Abdoulaye Doucouré, Iliman Ndiaye, Jesper Lindstrøm, Dwight McNeil
- Forward: Beto
Substitutes:
- Tim Iroegbunam (for Doucouré, 79’)
- Jack Harrison (for Armstrong, 62’)
- Bradley Moon
Southampton (4-4-2)
- Goalkeeper: Alex McCarthy
- Defenders: Taylor Harwood-Bellis, Nathan Wood, Charlie Taylor, James Bree
- Midfielders: Adam Lallana, Lesley Ugochukwu, Flynn Downes, Ryan Fraser
- Forwards: Joe Aribo, Adam Armstrong
Substitutes:
- Mateus Fernandes (for Lallana, 45’)
- Ben Brereton (for Fraser, 63’)
- Tyler Dibling (for Cornet, 63’)
- Ross Stewart (for Armstrong, 79’)
Everton vs Southampton First Half Highlights
Everton struck first in the 20th minute through a well-placed header by Abdoulaye Doucouré, capitalizing on a corner from Michael Keane to make it 1-0. Southampton, however, fought back swiftly. In the 32nd minute, Taylor Harwood-Bellis equalized with a towering header following a cross from Charlie Taylor, leveling the score at 1-1. Both teams had opportunities, but the half ended with no further goals.
Everton vs Southampton Second Half & Full Time Summary
The second half saw both teams trading chances but failing to break the deadlock. Everton’s Jesper Lindstrøm and Iliman Ndiaye were involved in several attacking plays, but Southampton’s defense, led by Harwood-Bellis and Nathan Wood, held firm. As full-time approached, chances continued to go astray for both sides, with Everton missing a crucial opportunity in added time.
At the end of 90 minutes, the match remained tied at 1-1, sending the contest into penalties.
Everton vs Southampton Penalty Shootout Drama
The penalty shootout was a tense affair, with both teams converting their initial spot kicks. However, in the final round, Ashley Young’s penalty was saved by Southampton’s Alex McCarthy, leaving James Bree to convert and seal Southampton’s progression to the fourth round.
Match Stats (Everton vs Southampton)
| Everton vs Southampton Stats | Everton | Southampton |
| Possession | 25.8% | 74.2% |
| Shots on Target | 4 | 4 |
| Total Shots | 14 | 11 |
| Fouls | 12 | 7 |
| Yellow Cards | 3 | 1 |
| Red Cards | 0 | 0 |
| Corner Kicks | 9 | 4 |
| Saves | 3 | 3 |
Everton vs Southampton Timeline
- 20′ – Goal (Everton): Abdoulaye Doucouré heads in from close range after a corner, putting Everton ahead 1-0.
- 32′ – Goal (Southampton): Taylor Harwood-Bellis equalizes with a header from a set-piece, making it 1-1.
- 45′ – Substitution (Southampton): Mateus Fernandes replaces Adam Lallana.
- 62′ – Substitutions: Ashley Young and Jack Harrison come on for Everton, while Southampton brings on Flynn Downes and Tyler Dibling.
- 79′ – Substitution (Southampton): Ross Stewart replaces Adam Armstrong.
- 86′ – Yellow Card (Everton): Jesper Lindstrøm for a bad foul.
- 90’+4 – Full Time: The match ends 1-1, heading into a penalty shootout.
- Penalty Shootout Drama:
- Everton and Southampton exchange successful penalties until Ashley Young’s miss in the final round.
- James Bree converts the decisive penalty for Southampton, winning 6-5 on penalties.
Everton vs Southampton Match Impact on Points Table
While this was a knockout fixture in the Carabao Cup and did not directly impact the league standings, Southampton’s victory propelled them into the fourth round of the competition, boosting morale for their upcoming league fixtures. Everton, despite their hard-fought performance, were eliminated from the cup, leading them to focus on their league campaign.
Everton vs Southampton Man of the Match: Taylor Harwood-Bellis (Southampton)
Taylor Harwood-Bellis delivered an exceptional performance for Southampton, not only scoring the crucial equalizer in regular time but also converting his penalty in the shootout. His defensive work, combined with his aerial presence, earned him the Man of the Match accolade.
The 2024-25 English Carabao Cup Third Round match between Everton and Southampton was a dramatic affair, full of twists and turns. Despite Everton’s strong start and numerous chances, it was Southampton’s composure during the penalty shootout that sealed the win. Both teams displayed great tenacity, but ultimately, Southampton advances, while Everton will reflect on missed opportunities in this thrilling cup tie.
